Ripple Labs legal chief believes SEC appeal could boost Ripple’s victory.

Ripple Labs legal chief believes SEC appeal could boost Ripple's victory.

Analyzing the Ripple Case Ruling and its Impact on the Blockchain Industry

The recent ruling in the Ripple case by Judge Analisa Torres has sparked significant discussions and debates within the blockchain industry. While concerns about a potential appeal by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) have surfaced, Ripple’s Chief Legal Officer, Stuart Alderoty, remains optimistic about the outcome and the implications it could have for the broader industry.

Ripple’s Defense and the Judge’s Ruling

Alderoty firmly believes that the judge made the right decision in determining that XRP does not constitute an investment contract. In his view, this ruling correctly interprets the law. He further suggests that a court of appeals might even amplify this decision in favor of Ripple.

Judge Torres’ ruling on July 13 stated that XRP was not a security when sold to the public on crypto exchanges. However, she also noted that it could be treated as a security when sold to institutional investors. This split-decision ruling presents an opportunity for the SEC to appeal or seek further review.

SEC’s Response and Possible Appeal

Following the ruling, the SEC used another ongoing case against Terraform Labs founder Do Kwon to express dissatisfaction with the outcome. The SEC lawyers argued that the portions of the Ripple ruling were wrongly decided and should not be followed. They emphasized that XRP’s retail sales should have been classified as securities.

SEC Chair Gary Gensler has also expressed his disappointment with the court’s decision, indicating that the regulator will continue to assess the ruling. However, these developments do not discourage Ripple’s legal team from defending their position in the event of an appeal by the SEC.

Ripple’s Potential Impact on Future Cases

Alderoty suggests that the ruling in the Ripple case could provide comfort to other judges presiding over similar cases involving the SEC. If the SEC continues to claim that crypto assets are securities, it may face more challenges in winning these cases. The ruling by Judge Torres sets a precedent that challenges the SEC’s stance and could influence future outcomes in favor of crypto companies.

The Need for a Clear Regulatory Framework

Despite the positive implications of the Ripple ruling, Alderoty emphasizes that the crypto sector still lacks a solid regulatory foundation. He criticizes the SEC’s regulation by enforcement approach, which has caused crypto laws in the United States to fall behind other jurisdictions. For the industry to thrive, it requires a rational, comprehensive, and understandable regulatory framework.

To illustrate the importance of a clear regulatory framework, Alderoty highlights how the SEC’s refusal to faithfully apply the law has hindered the growth and progress of the blockchain industry in the United States. As a result, the U.S. has become increasingly outpaced by other countries in terms of crypto development and innovation.

During the legal proceedings, XRP has demonstrated resilience in the market. As of the latest data from Cointelegraph, XRP is trading at around $0.70, recording an impressive 43% increase in the last month. This uptrend suggests that market participants have reacted positively to the Ripple case ruling and its potential implications for the broader crypto market.


The Ripple case ruling has undoubtedly captured significant attention within the blockchain industry. Ripple’s Chief Legal Officer, Stuart Alderoty, remains confident in the judge’s decision and is prepared to defend their position should the SEC appeal. The ruling has the potential to reshape future cases involving the SEC’s classification of crypto assets as securities.

However, while the ruling brings hope, it also underscores the urgent need for a clear and comprehensive regulatory framework in the United States. The SEC’s enforcement-focused approach has held back the industry, leaving it lagging behind other jurisdictions. It is crucial for regulators to foster an environment that encourages innovation and growth while protecting investors.

As the legal proceedings in the Ripple case continue, the blockchain community will closely monitor how this landmark ruling shapes the future of the industry.